Home / health and wellness / Modern Veterinary Medicine v.s Holistic Veterinary Medicine

Modern Veterinary Medicine v.s Holistic Veterinary Medicine

Understanding the difference between these two approaches to your dog’s and cat’s care can help you to better support your companion animal‘s short and long-term health in partnership with your veterinarian...

Practitioners of Modern Veterinary Medicine
It is important to understand that practitioners of modern medicine also called allopathic medicine (human, canine, feline, etc.):
  1. Are trained to understand and expertly perform standard and emergency medicine;
  2. Modern medicine is designed to address illness and disease post development;
  3. Modern Medicine is designed to react to and treat acquired conditions, it is not designed to strategically enable and maintain overall health and well being. If your veterinarian has:

    • Either informally or formerly studied overall health and well being in addition to their standard 4 yr Veterinary Science university course then it is fair to expect that they are in a viable position to advise you beyond standard and emergency healthcare.

Most companion animals owners do not realize that the university Veterinary Sciences course focuses on emergency health care, not preventative health care and in the absence of this realization unrealistic and unfair expectations can occur…

In all fairness:

  1. You should not expect your Veterinarian to be viably knowledgeable about:
    • Nutrition, toxins and carcinogens present in foods and medications and;
    • As nutrition is a fundamental factor in achieving good chronic care you should not expect them to be able to advise you on achieving a total care and/or chronic care regimen – they should be able to advise you on portions thereof.
  2. To have such an expectation that they can advise you on the entirety is not realistic;
  3. And in the best of worlds, in return the Veterinarian:
    • Should not lead you to expect that they are in a position to advise you fully and viably regarding diet and chronic care unless they have done additional studies (formal or informal) on these subjects.

When this mutual recognition of expectations is not respected your companion animal can end up having his/her health seriously impacted.

To exemplify this – some of my clients are doctors – practitioners of modern medicine, and they themselves have confirmed this to me;

    • In addition they tell me that they know little to nothing about nutrition:
    • They also note that if they did they would be in a much better position to help their patients.

Practitioners of conventional modern medicine excelat emergency medicine – it is what they are trained to do. They are not trained to prevent illness and disease. They are trained to understand and deliver emergency treatment.

Nutrition is not always considered a first response or major consideration in emergency treatment;
  1. Which is why nutrition is not a focus during their four years of Veterinary Science at university;
    • During a four year course on Veterinary Science the veterinary student spends about one week (40 to 50 hours) studying nutrition;
    • In addition,  the course material on nutrition is comprised of study material (text books, study aids and even the course material) is sponsored by and in many cases 100% provided by the big-name pet food manufacturers;
      • As such the Veterinarian student is not taught about the harmful ingredients present in commercially manufactured dog and cat food;
      • The end-result is that they are not provided the opportunity to study and understand why those ingredients are harmful;
      • Nor are they provided with an understanding of what constitutes a healthy alternative. 
      • The reason Veterinarians sell Prescription Dog and Cat Food (i.e. Royal Canine, Hill’s, Purina) that is seriously harmful to your companion animal, is becase they simply do not realize that the products are extremely harmful.
  2. Illness and disease develop when diet is poor, which also contributes to poor mental health, which then effects behaviour and spirit (i.e. being in an anxious state);
  3. When you understand the strengths and limitations of your veterinarian’s background you can then inform yourself so that you do not rely on him/her for advise in areas where he/she cannot provide viable information. 

Holistic Practitioners of Veterinary Medicine
Holisitic practitioners focus on treating the whole being – so understanding nutrition is of  great importance. Holistic practitioners of medicine (veterinary, canine, feline, etc.) use Complementary and Alternative (CAM) medicine (human, canine, etc.). Cam includes:
  • Acupuncture;
  • Ayurveda;
  • Chiropractic medicine;
  • Energy medicine;
  • Herbalism;
  • Homeopathy;
  • Meditation and hypnosis (human);
  • Naturopathy;
  • Nutritional-based therapies;
  • Nutritional medicine;
  • Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM);
A simple example of the difference in approach between conventional and holistic medicine can be seen in how chronic yeast-based ear infections are dealt with…
Conventional Veterinarian:


  1. Prescribe antibiotics to treat the infection;
  2. When the ear infection re-occurs, more antibiotics will be prescribed;
  3. An ear cleaning solution may also be prescribed (many of these contain toxins – the veterinarian is not trained to identify additives and toxins in prescription and over-the-counter medicants);
  4. This protocol is in keeping with emergency medicine – which is what they are trained to do;
Some veterinarians may also try to identify the ongoing cause of the ear infection by doing a series of allergy tests, which may or may not come up with conclusive findings;
  1. The veterinarian may suggest an alternate food, and in many cases they will try to sell you one of the foods that they are selling;
    • Two problems with this:
      • If the veterinarian knows little about nutrition then:
        • They may not be able to bridge the gap between inconclusive test results and the likely cause of the food allergy;
        • They will not know what food or foodstuffs to suggest as a healthy alternative;
        • And they will not  know how to analyze dog or cat (dry and wet) food ingredients, additives independently from the manufacturers claims – the veterinarian cannot assess the real health-value of the food.
Holistic Veterinarian
  1. Will avoid the use of antibiotics to treat the chronic ear infection;
  2. Will treat the immediate symptoms and the outer manifestations of the infection with natural interventions such as those in this article.
  1. Will ask what type of food the dog/cat is currently eating, and ;
  2. Will make immediate suggestions to change the diet, and;
  3. May suggest a one time detox protocol.
In Conclusion…
  1. If you like and trust your veterinarian then you dont need to switch to another veterinarian, but;
  2. You do need to take some of the responsibility for knowledge awareness, and:
  • Understand that there may be some limitations to what your Veterinarian can advise you on;
  • To ensure your companion animal attains and maintains optimal health you need to do a little research on nutrition and alternate health care.

About Karen Rosenfeld

My name is Karen Rosenfeld. I am an holistic diet nutrition health and wellness practitioner for dogs and cats. I am an holistic behaviorist for dogs. I offer a wealth of real-time, real-life experience. 30 years working and living with dogs and cats. Companion animals are my life, my work, my passion. Maintenance of Health Health Issues and Conditions Custom designed whole food diets, raw and cooked. Recommendations for commercial whole food diets. Consultations available worldwide via FaceTime, FaceBook video and voice, Skype, Phone and email Recommendation and specification of... Species Appropriate: Whole foods Treats Herbs Alternative medicines Supplemental foods Treatment and Remedy Holistic Behaviorist Services for Dogs Include: Obedience Training Behavior Modification Psychological Rehabilitation In-person Sessions Sessions available worldwide via FaceTime, FaceBook video and voice, Skype, Phone Affiliations to Companies None. I don’t sell food or supplements. I am NOT aligned with any companies. I prefer to select best solutions for my individual clients’ situation. My client services are available around the world. 🇺🇸USA 🇨🇦Canada 🇬🇧UK 🇦🇺Australia 🇪🇺Europe 🇨🇷Costa Rica and other Central American Countries 🇦🇪United Arab Emirates 🇸🇪Sweden and other Scandinavian Countries 🇸🇬Singapore and other Countries in Asia etc. Consultations and Sessions 📧Email: karen@ottawavalleydogwhispererer.ca 📞Phone: 1-613-293-3707 📱FaceTime 📱FaceBook video or voice 💻Skype 📖Holistic Wellness eBooks custom designed to suit 🚶In-person Sessions only available in Ontario, Canada.

Check Also

Skunk Spray Home Remedies for dogs, cats

Skunk Spray Removal Home Remedies for Dogs, Cats

If your dog or cat has the unfortunate experience of being sprayed by a skunk, …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.